Gospel Exercises — Volume II · Exercise 5 of 12
The Need for Confirmation and a Heart Closed to the Gospel
Before you begin: Please read the Introduction — How to Practice the Gospel Exercises
Reflection on John 7:17–18; Matthew 9:16–17
Prayer
Spirit of truth, free me from the need to hear only what confirms my own ideas. Give me the willingness to receive Christ's word even when it disrupts my established way of thinking. Make my heart a new wineskin for the new wine of the Gospel.
Amen.
Reflection
In John 7, Jesus says: “If anyone is willing to do His will, they will know whether this teaching comes from God or whether I speak on My own authority.” Our ability to recognize Christ's teaching therefore does not depend solely on reason or the amount of knowledge we have. It depends on our inner disposition.
If we are willing to do God's will, we can recognize that Jesus' teaching comes from the Father. But if our primary concern is to preserve our own ideas, we judge Christ's word by whether it confirms them.
We may appear to be listening while inwardly we are already waiting for particular words. We have an idea of what the speaker must say, what they must emphasize, and how they must put a particular matter into words. We are then not listening with complete openness. We are waiting to hear confirmation of what we already carry in our minds.
When the expected words do not come, we may feel tension, disappointment, or distrust. We may stop regarding someone we had previously listened to as an authority. Sometimes we can no longer receive even the other true things they say. The problem may lie not in what they said, but in their failure to say exactly what we needed to hear.
Seeking Confirmation Instead of Truth
It is right to discern whether someone speaks the truth. The Gospel does not ask us to accept every human word without thought. We come into conflict with the Gospel, however, when we judge what we hear by whether it fits our own inner framework rather than by Christ's teaching.
We may then think we are defending the truth while actually defending the way we have organized it in our minds. We expect others not only to speak truthfully, but also to confirm our emphases, concepts, and ideas.
We then accept authority only conditionally. We listen to it as long as it tells us what we expect to hear. But when something goes beyond our framework, or a sentence we considered essential is missing, that authority loses its weight for us. Outwardly, we listen to another person, but keep the final word for ourselves.
New Wine and Old Wineskins
In Matthew 9, Jesus says that new wine is not poured into old wineskins. The Gospel is not merely another idea we can fit into our existing way of thinking without anything in us changing. Christ's word brings new life, and so we need to be willing to have our thinking renewed.
An old wineskin may be our conviction that we already know exactly what God must say. It may be our need for every authority to emphasize the same things we do. It may also be our inability to accept a truthful message when it is expressed differently or reveals another aspect of reality.
We do not want to reject the Gospel openly. We want to receive it, but only on condition that it remains within our old framework. We want new wine without a new wineskin. This is impossible. The Gospel does not come merely to confirm us in what we already think. It comes to convert us.
Willingness to Act Comes Before Understanding
Jesus does not say that we must first understand everything correctly before we can do God's will. He says that if we are willing to do God's will, we will recognize His teaching.
Willingness therefore comes before understanding. We need to be ready to say: “If this word comes from You, Lord, I am willing to let it change me.”
This is where our lack of openness is revealed. We may want to know the truth, but we do not want it to cost us anything. We do not want to lose our familiar outlook, our certainties, or our image of ourselves.
We then listen not in order to be converted, but to find out whether we can remain as we are.
Sometimes we reject a true message simply because the speaker did not use the words we expected or emphasize what we would have emphasized. Yet failing to mention something does not necessarily mean denying it.
We therefore need to ask: are we rejecting something that is actually false, or are we simply troubled because our own idea has not been confirmed? Christ does not call us to measure the Gospel by our own framework. He calls us to surrender our own framework to the Gospel.
Discernment
Let us recall situations in which we listened to a sermon, a spiritual reflection, a conversation, or advice while inwardly waiting for a particular sentence.
What happened within us when that sentence did not come? Did we feel tension, disappointment, or irritation? Did we begin to regard the speaker as unreliable or spiritually weak? Did we stop receiving the other true things they said?
Let us notice exactly what we need to hear from others in order to continue taking them seriously. Do we require them to use our concepts, spell out all the points we emphasize, and express things exactly as we have arranged them in our minds?
Let us ask ourselves:
Do I listen to receive the truth or to obtain confirmation? Do I judge what someone actually said, or primarily what I think they should have said? Can I accept a truthful message even when it does not meet my expectations? Am I prepared to allow Christ to change my way of thinking? Or do I expect Christ to speak only within the framework I have already created?
Resolution
During the coming week, let us notice a moment when we feel inner tension as we listen to someone because they have not said what we expected.
Let us not reject their words immediately. Let us remain silent for a moment and try to discern:
What did this person actually say? What did I expect from them? Does what they said contradict the Gospel, or only my established framework?
Throughout the week, let us strive to read and listen to the Gospel so that it may bring us to conversion, rather than simply confirm our views.
Prayer
Our Father…